Gardner saw his power numbers increase to a career high 17 last season. However, he is probably better off walking and getting on base more. Gardner also saw his average dip to a lowly .217 in the second half of the year. He ended the year with a WAR over 3, and his former teammate Curtis Granderson is nothing special anymore. Gardner is a good player and a key one for the Yankees.
Edge: Yankees. Gardner exceeded his former teammate in terms of play a couple of years ago.